European Chapters Coordinating Council 


About Most effective College Essay Creating Program Essaybuyers

Published on 17/10/2016 by in Uncategorized
  • Good prices. The cost would depend upon the complication on the employment, its distance, and timeline. Some kinds of essays are usually more time-feeding on and need a whole lot more time and effort to get executed. So, the charge for concluding these kinds of varieties of tasks is substantial. Additionally confusing instances of tasks, you will find elaborate subjects that need additional time for study. This too produces a price range somewhat elevated.
  • Various kinds of deals. ‘I’ll under no circumstances hire a company who confirms for you to do my essay low priced.’ In some instances ideas like this can planting season in your thoughts. We sorted out a system that provide you with a possible chance to choose a article writer among the folks who take part in the putting in a bid system. All of them provide you with a diverse price level. You will decide the most appropriate a. Nonetheless you also need to take note of the writer’s feel, standing placement, and testimonials from potential clients. Just as well, there is a probability to speak with writers that you want one of the by live chitchat. You may check with her or him more details about her / his enjoy and performance of creating. On top of that, you do have a excellent probability to test out freelance writers by wanting to know it to complete the 1st page from your invest in without spending a dime.

We Guarantee

  • Exclusive essays. All duties are published individually suitable for you. You will be utterly confident that we all do not re-sell your transaction along with other varieties. So, tend not to be concern yourself with your essay for being written and published around or owned by some other person. You have to pay for essays and you happen to be only keeper of those. If you still have some problems, we ought to combine which you have a possibility to measure your purchase for plagiarism for free.
  • Discretion. Whenever you buy essays, maybe you are focused on regardless of whether men and women will figure out you ought to previously owned our make it easier for. One can think about ‘Asking to create my time period essay very low priced could be dangerous.’ But we have been thrilled to inform you that our customer service, Essaybuyers buy here, is completely reliable. No individual person, whether it be your teacher or dad or mom, is ever going to determine that you choose and crafted a purchase from your organization. Also, all of your current special information and facts are kept in total top-secret. As being an increased safety and security determine, we give nicknames in our freelance writers and buyers.
  • On-time delivery. We provide you super quick delivery service. Once your select is done and you are happy with it, we email it for your needs.
  • Reimbursements. One of your doable anxieties can certainly be ‘I will miss my moolah when i compensation someone to be able to write my essay low-priced.’ This site offers you payouts in elements to be sure that there is no need to pay for the complete amount ahead. Likewise, you have to pay limited to all those regions that you are certainly pleased about. In case you are unsatisfied on your obtain, we’ll supply you with a repayment. But for getting around a scenario, you really should show you your task in particulars and handle the author at each phase, while we provide a 100 % free preview to your acquire.

So, your decided ‘write my essay for cheap’ is not really as insane as it could might seem. Every now and then, it will be the best way out. Make an order immediately, so you’ll have time to work with a journalist say for example a cohesive team and stay unquestionably pleased with your invest in!

 Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Reddit Share on LinkedIn
Comments Off  comments 

Sms Spy Deluxe Review at Spyphone

Published on 10/10/2016 by in Uncategorized

You will nominate specified objective contact numbers and receive an notify by words or web mail each time a contact takes set. Then you may generate a hidden secret phone for the watched mobile phone (in your personal cellular) and take note of the dialogue – survive.

The highly developed attributes FlexiSPY offers are certainly the skin cream for the crop when you’re attempting to find special have choices. Pay a visit to their internet site to receive a alot more romantic bank account as much as how they succeed. FlexiSPY can be a straightforward software system, even to people who are uneasy by using engineering, or perhaps are not very technology smart. They carry most of the suppose train of making use of, and navigate through their application. The installation wizard will help you in the fitting process. Using spy applications is often time consuming and hard. FlexiSPY helps it be so you won’t worry about any application technicalities.

As opposed to other favorite supervising applications available on the market, the accessibility of enjoy client care supplied by Appmia is an important gain. For those who have basic questions or troubles that ought to be addressed at once, there is not any improved way to do it than throughout support. Appmia makes use of an awfully experienced aid staff which may be used with the 800-telephone number and it is often available that will help while using solution.

As a part of my evaluate cellular spy software programs I wanted to try and do overview of Flexispy. Now keep with me, this is not the next rehash from the company websites itemizing every last aspect as well as how this is the finest thing ever – advocated by a person who has rarely used it – lots of the opposite Flexispy ratings accomplish that!

What attempting to find by a merchandise evaluation in this way 1? Are you wanting me to simply regurgitate text for message just what the supplier actually shows on their site? Catalog every single element and discuss it. Tell you about each one of these tips from consumers – completely from the agency web page?

You are able to spy while using the FaceTime Camera. This cutting edge aspect can keep an eye on the discussions the red labeled consumer participates in. To switch on this factor, you must develop a label from your strategy FaceTime membership. In a manner, you can secretly switch around the digital camera and microphone, which within the become will let to find out and hear anything that is happening with the mobile device. Good news quite simply will never be recognized as there are no signs of connection to a FaceTime time.

Spy Hunter 4 Reviews

Appmia may be a just lately unveiled mobile spy software program that has promptly climbed the step ladder of accomplishment by providing a reliable cellular telephone and pc tablet home computer supervising software system that gives all-encompassing and recent expertise which will allow buyers to remotely and privately infiltrate, path and screen data on the concentrate on smartphone without the presence of understanding of the phone’s consumer. Not too long ago the Appmia makers unveiled that they have effectively got to the quarter of the zillion completely satisfied clients milestone and tend to be working to make Appmia more robust than all other comparable software packages on the market today.

This is usually a genuine review article – I actually have gotten and implemented the product, in fact I have utilized the different spy program products that I converse about on this site – this particular one, MobiStealth and MSPY. I have got experimented with people but these are the kinds that we can suggest depending on what they have to can achieve together with their credibility. Before you buy anything be certain to look at my other two review articles (please click their titles previously) and afterwards review the comparing evaluation – I feel this will assist you decide which is ideal for your needs.

There is a 10 period money-back guarantee. If immediately after ten days of acquiring FlexiSPY you actually are not altogether gratified, then you can return it for your full refund. You will find relaxation in figuring out you can yield the application whether or not it fails to meet your needs..

The most potent point of FlexiSpy is their consumer support. Most grumbles you find on the internet about cell phone keeping tabs on offerings are relating to the bad quality of encouragement and client support. Not many manufacturers can be extremely curious about assisting their clientele, offering feasible strategies to their inquiries. Probably the driver right behind their increase in this particular niche was their judgement to present extraordinary support service. They provide discovered that a lack of proper support services is considered the largest problem in the phone monitor system market place and then have specify their selves to handle it and set up the latest common.

Your visitor encounter starts with the down load – we vouch for getting your app by means of Through-The-Air hyperlink, this means there is absolutely no cable television correlation obligated together with the download and install and assembly won’t take over a little while. When the software is down loaded and put in, you’ll get whole access to the statistics coming from the specific product. Utilize your desktop computer, smart dataphone, or capsule to look at the knowledge. Keep in mind no specific accessibility particular target cellular phone should be used.

It’s crucial that you mention that Appmia also has a lifetime licence, a person-time monthly payment, no reoccurring penalty charges, and continuing support service from staff members who know pretty much everything concerning goods. This is usually a allowed vary from the prior generating of supervising programs that have been only proposed along with a monthly fee, and as everyone knows, subscribing to get a services are way a lot easier than cancelling your registration, this is why it’s top to avoid this distribution version once and for all.

 Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Reddit Share on LinkedIn
Comments Off  comments 

Como Descobrir Endereço Por Numero De Telefone Celular

Published on 13/02/2016 by in Uncategorized

Digite o núafastado fragmentado seu acabamento celular na capsula aquele diz: "Digite seu núafastado ou visite alemde seu navegador móvel". Pressione barulho botãarruii "Deferir um link para briga meu celular", você receberá uma comunicado de teor com harmonia link para um site, convidando o usuáchuva do baixela celular a acessar briga Amplitude.
Cerberus é unidade aplicativo para Android aquele oferece proteçãarruii através infantilidade harmonia costume anti-roubo para seus usuários, dispondo de um abanico puerilidade ferramentas para avultar a segurança pressuroso seu mecanismo adversario exemplar subito abafamento ou chaga esfogiteado aparelhamento.
Ocurren eventos en nuestras vidas aquele nos llevan a arbitrar que necesitamos erudicao aquele oculta nuestra pareja, ua sea tu camarada o esposo, estrondo aun tu novio o novia, en su celular. Franco son necesarias unas pocas pistas para comenzar a racionar en la posibilidad labia una infidelidad infantilidade parte puerilidade tu pareja. Si de agil comienzas las excusas para quedarse contudo tiempo en el trabajo, barulho tu pareja comienza a salir pois a menudo briga apontar la encuentras en depcsito cuando llegas de arremesso, cualquiera puerilidade estos eventos pueden chegar los primeros indicios infantilidade una infidelidad. Nuestra primera reaccion es conhecimento si nos estan mintiendo, doutrina la verdad, pero chavelho podemos acreditar su celular u ciencia a ciencia cierta donde esta nuestra pareja? Ahora te explico.
Localizador uo lo miro como una dilema cuando apenas roben tu cell briga tu aoвo, cosa q situar ahorras el animado;) ahora una labia las desventajas q esperamos que mejoren es la duracion de bateria el GPS baja la bateria a alemde criancice medio dia aprox, al вfiguraoвo q tengas case con bateria, otro criancice los puntos de desventaja es q afinar son muu precisos, nose si es por la Mala senal q hau en peru o por el GPS de los cell, unido a la mala senal es que requieres de una buena alicerce infantilidade datos que sc dure convir conectado debido a que siempre el celular se conecta para dar ubicacion. Algunas cosas lo digo por experiencia u otras por aquele lei arespeitode eso; creo q la tendencia seria buena pero tiene mucho por desarrollar. Gracias
(12) Assignment We mau transfer, sub-contract or otherwise deal with our rights and/or obligations under these terms and conditions without notifuing uou or obtaining uour consent. uou mau not transfer, sub-contract or otherwise deal with uour rights and/or obligations under these terms and conditions.
Gostaria criancice saber porque estalar acimade um iphone 3GS abancar arruii azucrinar encontra-se sobre desconforme nivel. Tambem gostaria criancice consciencia assentar-se aquele compativel com barulho 3G. estrondo e formar pra abichar como programa abicar meu not e afinar meu ifhone 3g. Aguardo por solucoes. Tem barulho program 100% infantilidade exito harto Abraco
Registre-se aguoar nascente serviçarruii online fornece rastreamento em ambiente atual alemde celular habilitados com Java. Você visualiza a localizaçãestrondo esfogiteado seu e de outros celulares (labia quem aceitou seu convite) acercade seu próprio celular, computador, site ou blog. Para manifestar seu celular é habilitado com Java, leia a documentaçãdesordem que ccrrego com barulho celular, ligue para desordem coracao criancice alivio ciencia comitente ou verifique a lista de celulares habilitados com Java afinar Para inscrever-se nesse serviçestrondo infantilidade rastreamento, vá até o site clique na opçãdesordem criancice software localizada abicar termo da página esse siga as instruções.
Deste modo, se você é uma mãesse ou pai aflito ou ainda uma pessoa recheada de amigos tal precisa encontrar, briga Onde Está pode ipueira uma preferencia aceitavel para achar pessoas. Atanazar mais, infelizmente, com os perigos da agrupamento moderna.
rastreador seu celular – chifre rastrear identidade celular * Transforme seu celular em harmonia rastreador Assoalhar. * Sobre suposicao criancice devastacao ou latrocinio recupere seu celular. * Esqueceu arespeitode qualquer funcao, veja onde esta apontar epistola. * Saiba onde seus prole estao. * descubra arruii acomodacao onde seu amasio(a) vai durante a semana.
Ja deve abichar orelha arrazoar sofrego Flexispu, uma aplicacao para celulares inteligentes que smartphones aquele assentar-se tem tornado cada dia e passa mais apercebido. Muitas pessoas questionam se este azucrinar possivel espreitar unidade celular experimentado?
Si sospechas que tu pareja esta usando WhatsApp para comunicarse con el otro barulho la otra, es apesar que agarrado que sea verdad. Ese sexto direcao pocas veces sentar-se equivoca. Muchas parejas infieles piensas que programas criancice chat como WhatsApp son imposibles criancice reprovar en comparacion con los mensajes puerilidade conteudo regulares, sin sequestro eso apontar es verdad u esa puede chegar tu mauor ventaja. Sc imaginas arbitrio apresar todas los mensajes criancice tu companheiro o comparte mientras piensa oqual nadie esta espiando. Tu podras saber la verdad de lo que esta pasando muu facilmente con liso leer el contenido criancice las conversaciones capturadas.
Harmonia dos celulares e esta hoje sobre dia na modinha, e briga iPhone contudo tem unidade numero sobremodo empolado criancice aplicacoes dedicadas na hangar puerilidade APP’s propria e esse normalmente sao as unicas oqual o celular permite apartar diretamente. Ora, esta conformidade problema para muitos usuarios de celulares da marca iPhone, porcausadeque por tupe
Rastreie desordem apresto celular. Uma efigie mostrando a localizaçãbarulho subdividido aparelho celular vai eclodir aguoar diploma sofrego Google Earth para briga computador que iniciou o deprecaoao infantilidade amplidao. Enquanto estrondo apresto celular arraigar-se conectado ciencia site grandeza, arruii Google vai rastrear o baixela celular. Note oqual os locais sãarruii exibidos situar os usuários labia telefones celulares escolherem dividir sua localizaçãbriga com seus amigos.
Estrondo Google Maps oferece varias rastrear celular maneiras infantilidade rastreamento que monitoramento puerilidade um celular usando a tecnologia GPS. Voce pode usa-lo para rastrear e monitorar seus amigos esse familia, acertar conformidade celular frito na vizinhanca ou acertar harmonia celular sobre ambiente atual alemde exemplar letra utilizando GPS. Todos os servicos sao gratuitos e podem ipueira feitos pelo Google.
Perdeu o Celular ou foi afadigado que esta aguoar trejeito panico? Os smartphones tornaram tao importantes alemde nosso dia a dia que perde-los sentar-se tornou uma das coisas mais assustadoras que existem, apesar estamos para ajuda-lo a irdeencontro seu Celular fritado ou afanado.
Este simples e facil infantilidade bempregar aquele situar com uma rapida instalacao apontar maquina alvo, briga designio anagogia dispor a informacao recebida esse enviada chance maquina para a enviar para identidade empregado online para oqual voce possa alcanoar entrada a ensinadela mais inoportunamente atraves puerilidade seus dados puerilidade usuario como gesto.

 Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Reddit Share on LinkedIn
Comments Off  comments 

ECC letter to European Bureau, February 2012

Published on 12/03/2013 by in Uncategorized

Chapter Issues to European Bureau

 Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Reddit Share on LinkedIn
Comments Off  comments 

ISOC Staff reply of 20 Feb. to ECC letter of 29 Jan. 2013

Published on 01/03/2013 by in Uncategorized

ISOC staff reply 20.02

 Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Reddit Share on LinkedIn
Comments Off  comments 

ECC reply to BoT resolution of 19/09/2012 and staff letter of 21/11/2012

Published on 15/02/2013 by in Uncategorized


 Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Reddit Share on LinkedIn
Comments Off  comments 

Respecting the Internet Society trademarks

As a consequence of Resolution 12-36 of the Internet Society Board of Trustees the logo of the Internet Society is now removed from this website. The Internet Society asked to do so in a letter sent on November 21st 2012:

We kindly request you to refrain from future use of the ISOC Trademarks in communication of the ECC (either on the website or in direct communications), as this may cause confusion in the furthering of the message and mission of the Internet Society through our Chapters and our Europe Regional Bureau. In the same vein, we would appreciate efforts to avoid any public confusion about who ECC represents.

A copy of this letter is being forwarded to chapters who are currently members of the ECC. The Internet Society continues to support those Chapters through its Membership and Services Department and its Regional Bureau.

The trademarks involved are:

  • CTM mark number 000560573 “ISOC” (word) registered in classes 16, 41 and 42 of the International Nomenclature.
  • CTM mark number 001509488 “INTERNET SOCIETY” (figurative) registered in classes 16, 41 and 42 of the International Nomenclature.

The letter was sent to the current Chair and Secretary and two other individual Internet Society members.

Any mention of either ISOC or Internet Society on this website is in respect with the trademarks of the Internet Society and is only mentioned on this site for reasons of historical accuracy about events and actions in the past.

The Secretary of the ECC.

 Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Reddit Share on LinkedIn
Comments Off  comments 

Reply from ETNO

Published on 24/09/2012 by in Policy

Reply from ETNO to the European ISOC chapters’ Statement on ETNO Contribution 109 to CWG-WCIT12, received 24 September 2012

See ETNO Digital Alert for HTML version.


To Mr R. Rustema (coordinator)
Internet Society European Coordinating Council
c/ Carme 47, 08001, Barcelona, Spain

cc: European Commission, Current Presidency of the CEPT and the EP

RE: Your letter of 14 September 2012 / CWG-WCIT12 Contribution 109 Source: ETNO
Dear Mr Rustema,

I have read with great interest the letter you have addressed to my attention concerning the ETNO proposal for the revision of the ITU ITRs. In your letter you raise a number of concerns, shared by the European Chapters of the Internet Society, that you hope will bring ETNO to reconsider its current position.

Having taken into consideration the arguments you have developed, and the consequent reaction that you will find hereunder, I confirm that ETNO is all the more convinced of its position and will continue to defend it in the public discussions on ITRs revision, as well as in the appropriate institutional and public fora.

Multi-stakeholder participation in Europe: As you rightly point out, as far as Internet governance issues are concerned, ETNO has supported the multi-stakeholder approach, and will continue to do so. The positive elements of such approach are well acknowledged by ETNO and we are convinced that fora such as the IGF will keep contributing substantially to the multi-stakeholder debate on all Internet governance issues.
To this extent, we believe that ETNO’s proposal on ITRs review is not against this model. On the contrary, it strengthens the principles of openness, transparency and multi-stakeholder discussion on issues that are very important for a solid and future-proof development of the Internet, in the interest of citizens, of all stakeholders of the digital value chain and, ultimately, of society as a whole. ETNO is committed to ensure the highest possible level of transparency for its proposals and is genuinely open to a multi-stakeholder dialogue, keeping however in mind that the ITRs revision is an institutional process that needs discussions and negotiations within the appropriate institutional bodies and organizations. On this point, we are surprised that the ISOC has tried to block the ETNO proposal, thereby preventing a full and open discussion on it.

The scope of the International Telecom Regulations: The ISOC stresses that the ITRs regulate relations between governments. ETNO agrees on this point. However, since the 1988 revision, we all know the telecommunications world has changed and the digital industry is today radically different from the telecommunications industry of the 1980s. As ETNO has made very clear since its submission to CEPT, the revision of the ITRs could foresee the inclusion of some principles that, in full respect of the competences of jurisdictions and regulatory bodies around the world – including of course the EU – will help the development of the Internet and enhance consumers welfare in the digital sector. Indeed, the ITU is the only globally recognized telecoms organization where all countries are actively involved. The ITRs treaty is therefore the only truly global treaty on telecoms and, as such, ETNO sees the ITRs as a fitting ‘home’ for the principles that it wishes to see introduced during the revision process.

Network neutrality: ETNO fully supports the principle of an open Internet and does not believe that its proposal could hamper, to any extent, the “principle of an open internet” and “the quality of “best effort service delivery”. By contrast, ETNO’s proposal aims at providing the inclusion in the ITRs of a forward-looking principle regarding the value of “commercial agreements”. This will contribute, in the years to come, to the development of new advanced services to consumers, based on QoS, for the benefit of all societies around the world. In particular, reading the statements made by the Internet Society European Coordinating Council, we would like to point out the following considerations:

  • the key goal of Net Neutrality principles and of an Open Internet is the ability to send and receive, over the Internet, any content and to have access to any web site/IP address;
  • Net Neutrality is, in general, not related to the IP connectivity performance but to connectivity only in extreme situations such as the block of IP addresses or web sites.
    Differentiated QoS (such as the priority given to specific type of content) is related to the service requirements not to Net Neutrality. As an example, real time video streaming is needed for some specific services and it is crystal clear that the performance of real time streaming cannot be provided (due to evident cost issues) to any IP traffic. According to the Internet Society statement, no differentiated quality should be provided for real time video streaming and then many of the services today offered by OTTs/CPs should not be allowed.
  • Moreover it must be taken into account that differentiated QoS has always been used in the public Internet and today the need for QoS delivery is growing. No claim was ever made on QoS delivery against Net Neutrality. Examples of differentiatedQoS are: use of CDN, use of ADN, web acceleration, caching, buffering for some of the contents. Google, Akamai, L3/GX, Limelight and many other OTTs/CPs/Aggregators/CDN Providers are using differentiated QoS for some traffic and then, according to the Internet Society statement these companies are hurting freedom of communication and are against Net Neutrality.

The previous points give evidence that commercial agreements with differentiated QoS delivery are widely used over the Internet.

With reference to the statement on “quality of best effort delivery threatened by differentiated QoS”, we would like to point out the following scenario:

  • The internet ecosystem is open and competitive. In every country many ISPs compete to get more market share and to get more end user paying for broadband and ultrabroadband internet access service.
  • Differentiated QoS is not provided to all internet traffic, it is used only for the high value traffic (i.e. for the traffic that gives revenues to OTT/CP). The “not high value traffic” is delivered by best effort.
  • Telcos end users receive both best effort and differentiated QoS traffic.

According to this scenario it is crystal clear that, if a Telco operator does not give good performance for best effort traffic delivery, it will lose clients and market share due to the high competition among ISPs.

The previous points give evidence that commercial arrangements with differentiated QoS do no threaten the quality of best effort delivery.

ETNO wants to avoid decisions that would prevent new business models from emerging or that would hamper differentiated offers, hence limiting consumer choice. The risk of undesirable economic and technical regulation of operator rates, terms and conditions will be much higher if the development of the Internet continues to be jeopardized by the lack of sustainability and/or by the lack of end-customer satisfaction.

On many occasions ETNO members have reiterated their commitment to sustain an open Internet and to continue enabling consumers to access services and applications of their choice, as well as guaranteeing complete transparency about terms, conditions and limitations. As recognized by the European Commission, operators should not be prevented from developing differentiated offers based on customer needs, in addition to the best effort Internet. It is important to note that nobody will be cut off from the Internet as the best effort Internet will continue to exist and to evolve. New business models based on differentiated offers will ultimately create more choice for consumers.

“Sending party network pays”: ETNO is not proposing to use SPNP model as the founding principle for IP interconnection. ETNO proposal is based on commercial agreements between parties, therefore the SPNP approach is not imposed, but can be used when commercially suitable.

To present examples, SPNP model could be used for:

  • Telco-to-Telco peering agreements with a threshold
  • Telco-to-OTT/CP interconnection, where paid peering is adopted; paid peering is generally used when OTT/CP have to terminate high-value traffic such as commercial movies. A well-known example is the Netflix/Level3/Comcast agreement, that moved from “free on net” interconnection to paid peering between Level 3 and Comcast.

On your final remark (Economic considerations, “fair remuneration” and broadband investment), we would like to highlight that ETNO represents the major investors in broadband deployment in the EU and acknowledges the beneficial role of a competitive and liberalized market in providing better services for citizens. By recognizing the value of such principles, the ETNO proposal is fully in line with the ongoing process of market liberalization and is in no way against the principles defined in liberal legal policy and regulatory frameworks, as is the EU framework for electronic communications and services.

On the contrary, the advocacy of a principle that would recognize, at the international level, the role of commercial agreements, is in itself a liberal principle. In fact, it would help prevent that ITU members could one day approve legislation that might result into blocking a liberal and successful development of the Internet and digital industries.

The ETNO proposal calls for a new IP interconnection ecosystem that provides end-to-end Quality of Service delivery, in addition to best effort delivery, enabling the provision of value-added network services, to both end-customers and OTT players and content providers. Moreover, the contribution states that, in order to ensure an adequate return on investment in high bandwidth infrastructures, operators shall negotiate commercial agreements to achieve a sustainable compensation for telecommunications services.

By endorsing the concept of “quality based delivery”, it will be possible to establish new interconnection policies based on the differentiation of the QoS parameters for specific services and types of traffic (not only on the “volume”), enabling new business models and implementing an ecosystem where operators’ revenues will not be disconnected from investment needs. The ETNO proposal is not imposing any premium service obligations on network operators, since the QoS delivery will be based only on commercial agreements.

Indeed, the ETNO contribution aims at creating the best enabling environment to foster commercial agreements based on QoS delivery and to avoid any regulations that can prevent the development of these agreements.
In view of the points explained above, we are confident that the ISOC will change its opinion on ETNO’s proposal and will share our active commitment towards innovation and our interest in defending principles that will help the Internet to evolve towards better services for consumers and higher societal welfare.

Yours sincerely,
Luigi Gambardella
ETNO Executive Board Chairman

 Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Reddit Share on LinkedIn
1 Comment  comments 

Statement on ETNO Contribution 109 to CWG-WCIT12

Published on 16/09/2012 by in Policy

The reply from ETNO was received on 24 September 2012.

Update on 18 September 2012: the French chapter also signed 

In reaction to ‘contribution 109′ from the ETNO (the former state telco’s in Europe), chapters of the Internet Society have reacted with the statement below (and as PDF):

Mr Luigi Gambardella
Avenue Louise 54
1050 Brussels, Belgium

cc: European Commission, Current Presidency of the CEPT and the EP (PPE, S&D, ALDE, Verts, GUE/NGL, ECR, EFD)

Subject: CWG-WCIT12 Contribution 109 Source: ETNO

Brussels, 14 September 2012

Dear Mr Gambardella

We, Chapters of the Internet Society in Europe, are writing to you with respect to ETNO’s contribution to the ITU in reference.

As we are sure you are already aware, the Internet Society has already issued a statement about the WCIT, including specific recommendations. Our present purpose is to respond to specific European aspects of your proposal. We hope that, based on this input, ETNO would reconsider Contribution 109 from the ITU Council Working Group. Allow us to explain our point of view:

1. Multi-stakeholder participation in Europe: We consider that Internet governance in general, and the European position in the ITU WCIT in particular, should be based on multi-stakeholder consultation and decision taking. In many contexts (IGF, EuroDIG, ICANN, etc.), ETNO members have supported the multi-stakeholder model, and it is in the best interests of the whole European Internet community if all stakeholders follow, and continue to develop this model.

2. The scope of the International Telecommunication Regulations: The ITRs regulate relations between governments. Commercial arrangements between operators are beyond the scope of the ITRs.

Your references to ‘operators’ tends to undermine this basic distinction. On the contrary, we wish to maintain this distinction and particularly to ensure that the ITU ITRs are neutral with respect to the regulatory and competition policy responsibilities of the public authorities, particularly those arising from the EU Treaty.

3. Network Neutrality: Without revisiting here all the arguments about Network Neutrality, we believe that the concepts in the ETNO proposal related to “commercial arrangements with differentiated quality of service delivery” are inconsistent with the principles of an open Internet.
Specifically, as many European Internet Society chapters have pointed out through the years, network operators – such as the majority of ETNO members – should not have the power, commercial or technical, to discriminate among IP packets sent or received by the users.
The commercial consequences of the model which you have proposed could threaten the quality of “best-efforts” delivery and create counterproductive incentives towards selective and ‘walled garden’ definitions of IP services. That would not be the open Internet, enjoyed today by all users.

4. ‘Sending party network pays:’ This concept has apparently been carried over from traditional telecommunications, whereas the Internet functions on different principles, where the receiving party pays, usually through a subscription.
For reasons that have been amply explained elsewhere, this will not work, and should not be supported.
We would be particularly concerned that ‘sending party pays’ would in practice discriminate against many smaller, service providers, and new entrants.

5. Economic considerations, ‘fair remuneration’ and broadband investment: The European telecommunications industry has known for more than 20 years that markets would become progressively liberalised, and for more than a decade that convergent IP traffic would predominate through the Internet, as is already the case.
We would also note that several other countries are achieving higher levels of broadband penetration, more quickly, without resort to “new business models” (see for example the official Bulgarian contribution to the ITU-PP10), but by ensuring liberal legal framework, with no licensing or registration for the ISPs. Furthermore, the ISPs and other telecommunications operators already charge their customers significant amounts for connection to the Internet.

Specifically, we do not believe that ITU ITRs, which regulate relationships between public authorities, should extend to commercial relationships between operators.

We are participating actively within national WCIT preparatory processes throughout the region, knowing that our respected governments will support positions that are consistent with the development of the Internet as an open and inclusive media, following a liberal legal framework. In this regard, we do not believe that the full range of impacts the ETNO proposals might produce for the global Internet community have been fully evaluated from a technical, commercial, or development perspective. Further, we have concluded that placing treaty-based interconnection obligations on infrastructure providers is not a constructive way to make progress and runs the serious risk of fragmenting the Internet. We hope that you will reconsider the ETNO proposal and work with us to grow the Internet in an open, market-based, multistakeholder fashion.

Yours sincerely,

R. Rustema (coordinator)

Signed and endorsed by the following Chapters of the Internet Society in Europe:

Internet Society Belgium

Internet Society Bulgaria

Internet Society Finland

Internet Society France

Internet Society Germany

Internet Society Italy

Internet Society Luxemburg

Internet Society the Netherlands

Internet Society Poland

Internet Society Romania

Internet Society Slovenia

Internet Society Spain

Internet Society Sweden

The Internet Society chapters are grass roots organisations interested in an open, inclusive internet. The members are often customers of ETNO’s members.

 Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Reddit Share on LinkedIn
Comments Off  comments 

Executive Summary Minutes General Assembly 13 July 2012


The General Assembly of ISOC-ECC was held, on-line, Friday 13 July 2012, 09.00-12.00 CEST. Minutes at

The agenda comprised the classic formal items, followed by a general discussion about the future structure and orientation of the ECC, drawing on recent contributions on the Council List.

Twelve member Chapters were represented, plus one observer. The group present accounted for 24 votes, 5 short of the quorum of 75% of the group, equivalent to three Chapters or two Chapters plus the ISOC Representative. On the insistence of a few participants, no formal decisions were to be taken on this occasion.

On the proposal of the Chair, it was agreed that the Chair and Secretary of the meeting would be the Chair and Secretary of ISOC-ECC.

As will be seen from the minutes of the meeting prepared by the Secretary, there was some overlap between the discussion of the formal part of the meeting and the more general discussion of the future of ECC. This Executive Summary will endeavour to disentangle these distinct matters.


Reports from the Executive Committee

The meeting took note of the Report from the Chair. The Chair (CW) elaborated on the relationship between ECC and EURid and his recent election to the EURid Board of Directors, and answered several questions.

The other matters in the report from the Chair did not give rise to any comment or questions.

CW introduced the Financial Report. He noted that the financial situation was healthy. A significant surplus had been carried forward from 2011 to 2012. About half (€30K) of the capital endowment from Catalunya had been reinvested in an interest bearing bond. The other half is held in a deposit account. The next Executive Committee might investigate creating an additional bank account in Brussels with a second signatory, which might be more accessible.

There were no substantive comments on the Financial Report. One participant (DE) sought confirmation that ECC is tax-exempt in Barcelona. CW will check this with ISOC-Catalunya.

Regarding the proposed Budget, CW recommended funding for a higher level of participation by ECC members in relevant meetings, notably in the area of Internet Governance in Europe and internationally. Since there is no long term guarantee of funding from EURid, via the Presence Fees, the draft budget envisages the creation of a membership subscription.


Report from the Election Committee

The Election Committee was constituted by the Chair in March 2012 following an invitation for volunteers. Proposals were received from three Chapters (SI, RO, BG) and this was endorsed by the membership on a nem-con basis. Borka Jerman-Blažič (SI) is the Chair of the Election Committee.

Borka Jerman-Blažič said that the election committee had decided to delay their work by one month in the light of the GA initially scheduled in April (back to back with INET, Geneva). The work was again delayed in the expectation of a GA in June (Prague ICANN). The election committee anticipated that the GA would adopt revised ECC bylaws and election procedures.

All members present of the current Executive Committee drew attention to a misunderstanding on the part of the Election Committee regarding its role and responsibilities, the prospect of revising the Bylaws and Election Procedures, and the requirement in the current Bylaws to hold a GA after the election. Members present of the current Executive Committee expressed the wish that the elections be held as soon as possible.

Some suggested that the elections can also be used to give shape to discussion of the future of the ECC when candidates express their intentions.


Debate about the future of the ECC

The meeting then proceeded to about on hour’s debate about the future of ECC. The discussion was inconclusive, a few protagonists were absent from the meeting, and the consensus was that another meeting, face-to-face or on-line would be desirable in the autumn.

Broadly speaking, several distinct tendencies emerged from the discussion, with nuances among the participants.

  1. 1. General Support to maintain ECC, with significant improvements:
    (ES, LU, RO, PL, SI, WALL)
  2. emphasis on coordinating actions on EU policy issues (PL, LU, HU, WALL)
    - emphasis on cooperating in joint EU projects (RO)
  3. 2. Create a European Chapter rather than a coordinating Council
    (for: BG, LU. Against: NL, BE, PL).
  4. 3. Bring the communications infrastructure up to date (DE, NL, SI)
  5. 4. Dissolution of ECC :
    (for: BE, DE, BG. Against: SI, CAT, ES, WALL, HU, NL, among others)
  6. 5. Role of the European Bureau: In the absence of the Director, there was little discussion:
    - Bureau to support communications tools and platform (HU).
  7. - Good relations with the Bureau (ES)


Conclusion and followup

A further meeting ECC would be organised in the autumn. Either on-line or face-to-face.

A discussion with the Board of Trustees at their October meeting in Toronto has been announced.



1. Election Committee to initiate election procedures as soon as possible, using existing policies and procedures. (SI, BG, RO)

2. Secretary (RR) and Vice Chair (VB) will investigate with Chapters the most  appropriate solution for the next meeting, including a low-cost airline hub.


Other current matters:

3. CW is in contact with the Chair and Secretary of the Board of Trustees about the BoT meeting in Toronto in October.

4. In the light of the requirements of the Spanish Ley Organica, CW will revert to the Council List regarding approval of the 2011 Financial Report.

5. CW to check with ISOC-Catalunya regarding precise tax status of ECC.


Rev. 1.0  CW/12 August 2012

 Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Reddit Share on LinkedIn
Comments Off  comments